Legendary
#1
98/100
2012 Toyota Highlander
$2,500 · 137,000 mi
≈$592/mo
Unknown
$13,034 below market
Best Used Toyota Highlander Deals
Informed auto decisions start here. Every used Toyota Highlander listing ranked on 12 factors with the full whyon every card — anchor price, retention curve, mileage adjustment, condition, accident history, owner count, and more. Today's top deals are below, ordered by deal score.
Search all used Toyota Highlander listings →
Live inventory
49
Median asking
$7,000
Median fair value
$11,821
Avg savings vs market
+31.3%
Best deal todayLegendary
Top 10 ranked deals
Legendary#298/1002005 Toyota Highlander$2,945 · 235,000 mi≈$601/moUnknown$5,220 below market
Legendary#398/1002004 Toyota Highlander$2,000 · 247,185 mi≈$582/moUnknown$6,100 below market
Legendary#498/100Toyota highlander$7,000 · 155,000 miUnknown$23,852 below market
Legendary#598/1002004 Toyota Highlander$3,500 · 227,333 mi≈$611/moUnknown$4,882 below market
Legendary#698/1002008 Toyota Highlander$2,200 · 245,000 mi≈$586/moUnknown$5,432 below market
Legendary#798/100Toyota Highlander$7,999 · 170,000 miUnknown$22,853 below market
Legendary#898/1002009 Toyota Highlander$3,000 · 246,464 mi≈$602/moUnknown$4,603 below market
Legendary#998/1002011 Toyota Highlander$3,800 · 126,000 mi≈$617/moUnknown$10,331 below market
Legendary#1098/100Toyota Highlander$5,998 · 217,652 miUnknown$24,854 below market
Frequently asked questions
How does MotorRank score Toyota Highlander deals?+
MotorRank scores every used Toyota Highlander listing on 12 factors: anchor price, retention curve, mileage adjustment, condition, accident history, owner count, usage type, title brand, dealer reputation, feature uplift, fuel economy, and trim profile. The output is a 0–100 deal score plus a verdict from Legendary to Meh.
What does a "Legendary" deal mean on a Highlander?+
A Legendary deal means the asking price is more than 30% below MotorRank's estimated fair value for that specific Toyota Highlander configuration (year, trim, mileage, condition, history) — roughly the top 1% of listings. Below that the scale is Epic (>10% below), Good (>0% below), Fair (within 5% above), and Meh.
How fresh is this Highlander inventory?+
Inventory refreshes every 30 minutes from auto.dev's national feed of dealer and private-seller listings. The deal scores recalculate on every refresh, so the ranked order reflects today's market.
Why are two similar Highlander listings ranked so differently?+
Two listings with similar price and mileage can rank very differently if one has a clean history (one owner, no accidents) and the other has multiple owners or accident records. Trim, drivetrain, certified pre-owned status, and dealer reputation also feed into the score.
Can I see the verdict for a specific Highlander listing?+
Yes — click any card above to see that listing's full 12-factor breakdown, including the deal score, savings vs. estimated fair value, and the specific factors that drove the verdict.
Is MotorRank free?+
Browsing deals, ranks, and per-listing verdicts is free. Premium tiers add saved searches with email alerts, unlimited AI rankings, and bulk listing analysis. See the Pricing page.
Scores update every 30 minutes from live inventory. Each verdict explains the 12 factors behind it — click any listing to see the full breakdown.